First, you guys should by now have realized how big of a crush I have on Death Cab for Cutie's music. It's like there's regular music which I have ordinate amounts of respect for and interest in...and then there's Death Cab which I can't compare to other music on the same plane because that would feel like blasphemy. I'm not sure why this is, but Ben Gibbards' voice just doesn't fit in with everything else when I hit shuffle. SO I obviously have very high expectations for new Death Cab music. I also rate their songs on my iTunes thusly: 5 stars for my favorites as in I am constantly playing these songs in my head, 4 stars for really really awesome songs that I listen to regularly, 3 stars for songs that I can sing along to, unrated if I don't have strong feelings on them.
I will say that this is a band for people who like sitting and listening to music through their own headphones. It's always weird for me to hear their songs at the Daily Grind because I think of them as such a personal musical experience. It's all very introspective and thought-provoking and I am such a fan of all of their work. I was really pleased on my first listen through their latest album though it is so short. It will definitely be listened to a lot - I listened through four times in the first 48 hours of owning it. (Side note...music is way better when you listen to it a full album at a time.)
Also, Death Cab has a couple of distinctive sounds. Sometimes they're poppy, sometimes they sound more electronic or distorted, and sometimes they are slow or repetitive or just have long stretches without vocals. I love it because I can put all of their music on shuffle and get all kinds of songs without any super jarring shifts. This is the best way for me to start studying for finals...once I've gone through all of their songs I know I need to get serious about my work.
Why am I SO into them? This is a good question deserving more than a portion of a post for its answer, but I will be as brief as possible. Basically I think they can cover any emotion. The lyrics kind of grow up with you and you can get more out of them as you experience more things in life, but the songs are still enjoyable even when you don't have a huge emotional connection to them. But the more I listen to them, especially when I'm going through emotions (which is, to be clear, a very rare occurrence...you'll recall I'm about half-Vulcan), the more the songs will play in my head and the lyrics will come up when they fit my situation much later on. And I swear, I took like a year break from listening to them (not intentionally, I just didn't listen to a lot of my own music during senior year), and they would still be coming up in my head, even the obscure ones that I couldn't actually remember listening to. Every time I listen to any of their songs it's like revisiting a memory. They just paint these distinctive pictures in my head because the lyrics are so oddly specific in places, the metaphors are crazy, and I can picture a sunrise in most of them.
I don't know, I know there are other really good artists out there and I don't mean to sound like I don't appreciate any other groups or individuals, but I haven't found any other music that makes me feel the same way. Some of it has to do with my exposure to it at such a formative age (probably 14?) in terms of making my own decisions and deciding what my tastes were and then it being there for me throughout the changes in my life. Although these new songs obviously haven't been there...except for this week...there's something great about this band that makes me feel like I'm home even when hearing these songs for the first time.
1. Home is a Fire (4 stars)
Sounds like Different Names For the Same Thing (one of my favorites)
On the first listen I was not a fan. I watched the video and thought it was kind of artsy, but it sounds a lot better without it in my opinion. It's one that grows on you (I think this is the case for all of their songs). The vocals are distorted and shift between this and a more clear bridge, which is kind of cool and experimentalist of them (as that's what they say they're doing with this, their seventh album...).
2. Codes and Keys (4 stars)
Sounds like an upbeater Title and Registration mixed with Brothers on a Hotel Bed
Kind of epic and soaring, fits in well with Translatlanticism or Plans. Though I like its sound, its lyrics are nowhere near as good as the older albums. It's too generic...and it's kind of positive, which is not a bad thing but it's a little out of character lolol. Very echoey. It starts strong and continues to build in intensity, and the end is definitely worth it musically but like I said the lyrics are just kind of...what are you doing.
3. Some Boys
Sounds like You Can Do Better Than Me and I Was a Kaleidoscope
Very energetic, has an electric undercurrent. Interesting lyrics - definitely something that makes me think in a Death Cab-y way. It could super grow on me or it could just be decent. It's kind of infectious but forgettable at the same time and I think it's really a very subjective song (not that all songs are objective...that would be weird). The sound effect that is not drums is really weird and it reminds me of someone breathing creepily. But otherwise it's got a nice keyboardy part and Ben's voice sounds like one of the very early albums.
4. Doors Unlocked and Open (4 stars)
Sounds like Meet Me on the Equinox (but better) and We Laugh Indoors
Good long musical intro, which granted sounds a bit elementary, great pulsing chorus, but the part between these two is very much like We Laugh Indoors though not quite as good. The lyrics are kind of cute. When we get to the actual heart of the song, it is wonderful...it's just catchy and makes me want to jam in a Death Cab way (which is to say with my headphones in and no one judging me).
5. You Are a Tourist (3 stars)
Sounds like Your New Twin Sized Bed or (vaguely) A Move Script Ending or (maybe) Marching Bands of Manhattan
A little bit too repetitive (which is usually one of the things I like about Death Cab). It's pretty standard Death Cab so obviously it's not a bad song. I think I just haven't listened to it enough to appreciate it...? Maybe it will go up in rating later.
6. Unobstructed Views (4 stars)
Sounds like I Will Possess Your Heart
Awesome slowly-building-in-intensity intro...though not anything really new, I still like it a lot. By my third listen I already knew which parts I was anticipating, and then it was very gratifying to hear them. It's just like musical funfetti cake. So delicious. However, it probably won't go up in rating as I listen to it because it doesn't quite have the depth or uniqueness of a 5 star song.
7. Monday Morning
Sounds like a happier Death of an Interior Decorator or Expo '86
Very poppy, very Transatlanticism-y. The chorus is kind of funny, but I like that it has a distinct voice (though not necessarily a unique style compared to older songs). I like the authenticity it offers (I mean this is a plus for any of their songs...).
8. Portable television (3 stars)
Sounds like The Sound of Settling or No Sunlight except way amped up
Great melody, starts off fast and keeps its momentum throughout. Overall I really like it, though it takes a pretty stark departure from more traditionally Death Cab sounds in that it is a very happy song though I still get the feeling that no one is happy.
9. Underneath the Sycamore (3 stars)
Sounds like Marching Bands of Manhattan (my favorite)
Though this is a good song, in comparison to Marching Bands it is not that great. It has a nice familiar sound, but it sounds a bit like two different songs glued together...sometimes this works really well, but I'm not a huge fan of it here.
10. St Peter's Cathedral
Sounds like Grapevine Fires or the end of What Sarah Said
Starts off with minimal music and grows into an epic song - but not in like a legit epic way, like epic in the actual meaning of the word. It ends on a weird ethereal note and doesn't go as far as it could have. It's also about how there's nothing more to a church than its architecture? It's not painful to listen to by any means but it's definitely not a favorite.
11. Stay Young, Go Dancing (5 stars)
Sounds like no other Death Cab song everrrrr
This does not sound like Death Cab at all, but I love it! It's a little bit like Owl City, a little bit reminiscent of Lord of the Rings for some strange reason to me. It's very cute, authentic, folksy almost. I love it! Also, it's about Zooey Deschanel (Ben Gibbards' wife). Perfection.
(It took me five days since I started this post to finish it...I love this album and didn't want to do it injustice by merely stating that and nothing more. But seriously.
Go listen to some Death Cab.)